Login to post. Membership required.
Now, seeing all the debating going on about the lack of crime because peopl don't want to die with the increasing cloning costs, here's an idea:
The possibility of giving prison sentences. Not very long ones - but I mean, for crimes like firearm possession, drug possession, not paying fines, et cetera, instead of shooting the perp on-site, if they come peacefully we cold give 'em something like a (small) fine and some prison time in that big-ass prison on Death Row. Not very MUCH prison time, but something to offset the cost of the fines or whatnot. Now, of course, it sucks to be locked in a room, so the large prison could be a series of rooms, where the cons can walk around and have things to do (Like making license plates for a teeny salary and whatnot), possibly make contacts, and get visits in the visiting room. There could be a lights-out schedule, such as if you're not in your cell by 9pm, the guards beat the crap out of you.
Stays would be short- something in the range of two days to a week, and only for minor crimes, like not paying a fine or drug possession, and would be a better alternative than getting shot for not paying a fine on time. I believe it'd encourage more petty crime and be a pain in the ass for us Judges, but still neat.
By Murphy at Mar 27, 2002, 11:00 PM
|
0
LEGEND
951 posts
From what i understand in the dome locking someone up is far worse than clone death. To take away someone's actual freedom is the worse sentence you can recieve. I've actually been told that i shouldn't cell people and that was just for a day or a few hours.
By allandra at Mar 27, 2002, 11:05 PM
|
0
CHUMMER
152 posts
It depends, most newer characters would rather go into a cell for a couple of days. Though some older more wealthy may differ.
By Mael at Mar 27, 2002, 11:11 PM
|
0
SPLATJOB
50 posts
Death is a 2000 fine if you get your gear back….I'd rather be in jail for a day and lose my drugs if that's what I'm caught for...ya know? it will increase crime, and fill upi jails
By Dominik at Mar 27, 2002, 11:12 PM
|
0
BATA
282 posts
The staff long ago decided that it was in the best interest of the player to not lock them up for long amounts of time. I, personally, don't have a problem with a few hours of sitting in a cell, but I agree with the prison sentences being non-existant.
By Johnny at Mar 27, 2002, 11:12 PM
|
0
JUSTICE
3,038 posts
As a player and having had characters that of course, live a life of crime, I actually would WANT to see jail time. That's my vote. If you don't want to use the jail, what the hell is it for?
By Frank at Mar 28, 2002, 8:52 AM
|
0
NEWBIE
18 posts
I don't think that you should pay a small fine -and- go to jail. Going to jail is the punishment in and of itself…it depends on how long the jail time would be. Now, as a quick sidenote, last time I checked, drugs were legal.
(Edited by Shadow at 11:23 am on Mar. 28, 2002)
By Shadow at Mar 28, 2002, 11:21 AM
|
0
SPLATJOB
63 posts
And another thing… if people in the IC world were really that diswrought over Jenna being the first clone and how F'n in humane it was, I'm pretty darn sure they would whine about how WJF kills like mad. I'm pretty darn sure they would have something to say about how killing is killing and wjf has no right to kill and FORCE someone into an already controversial clone. Lets keep a level of balance here, people.
-Jail IS a reasonable option-
Here are some suggestions to make it work right:
Upon apprehension and before the Judges make their "desicion" they should imprison the perp. Upon which time, they will be there (in jail) for a short period of time (couple hours to two days) to sweat over what their punishment is going to be, however severe.
The jail needs to be used more, plain and simple... let me continue.
If death is the sentence, then there should be an execution (public if needs be... I can see good TV rating opportunities here... maybe even broadcast over public SIC, stating who's death it is and for what crimes).
If death isn't the case, THEN the person should have to PAY a fine to get OUT of jail. Makes sense. If they can't afford it (check their bank account, of course) then make them work to pay it off while in jail.
By Frank at Mar 28, 2002, 12:21 PM
|
0
NEWBIE
18 posts
Yeah, but that was in 2015 - ICly, that's 72 years ago. That means two generations have grown up with human cloning being a reality - it just took some getting used to, like TV. Now, IRL, TV is everywhere, but 70 years ago it was a completely outlandish idea, and nobody had one.
By Murphy at Mar 28, 2002, 12:28 PM
|
0
LEGEND
951 posts
True, desinsitization happens, but we're not talking about inventions that make life easier… we're talking about moral issues that shock and caues general horror to the public. �
IRL the tv was embraced because it was useful and fun. �However, the IRL death sentence has declined drastically and jail time stretched out. �70 yrs ago IRL we had mobsters openly gunning people down in the street... now that kind of thing doesn't exist openly. �Other than the petty gang wars. �I should know, I lived in the ghetto of downtown Las Vegas. �I know shootings happen, I've had bullets whiz by my head. We didn't get desensitized to voilence in the streets... we stopped it.... for the most part... and that has to do with jail time.
(Edited by Frank at 12:49 pm on Mar. 28, 2002)
By Frank at Mar 28, 2002, 12:46 PM
|
0
NEWBIE
18 posts
Yes, and I live in Montreal, where the Hell's Angels and the Rock Machine have been going at it for the past ten years. I have a nice view out my front window because the entire block diagonally across from me no longer exists.
And TV is only useful as a propaganda tool, and no, it isn't fin because all the good shows (like Millenium) get cancelled.
Speaking of shocking and horrifying people, how about all these reality TV shows, like Fear Factor and Tempation Island? They've only been around for a couple years, are you continually horrified or have you gotten used to 'em yet? What about Richard Simmons and Bob Saget? Have they not become regular, every day horrors? Are you not desensitized to them? How about when they clone yet another sheep? Do you actually care? I don't. Sure, clone more sheep. Let there be sheep!
Hell, thirty years ago you didn't find sex shops and lap dance parlors and swinger's clubs every street corner, but now you do. And it's normal.
The Internet, that's another thing. The only people who are still concerned about it these days are the ignorant and media barons who see their televised filth having less effect than it should, because people now have access to hundreds upon thousands of opinions and facts on the 'net. And we're used to it, and I'm used to it and it hasn't been around all my life.
More and more radical technologies are being produced and quickly accepted - future shock isn't much of a reality anymore. Hell, did you know cybernetic legs are already on sale IRL? 10k each, yeah, but you can walk and jog with them, you can even feel hot and cold and touch with them. Not as good as the real thing, but still..it's there and no one's making a fuss.
72 years is plenty of time to integrate something, no matter how radical, into everyday life. If the old generation can't handle it, screw them, the new one will.
By Murphy at Mar 28, 2002, 1:00 PM
|
0
LEGEND
951 posts
Sooo… what did all that ranting have to do with your original Jail inquery that I supported to begin with? :)
(Edited by Frank at 1:04 pm on Mar. 28, 2002)
By Frank at Mar 28, 2002, 1:03 PM
|
0
NEWBIE
18 posts
Your comment about Fear Factor and other reality shows: Stupid people doing stupid things doesn't shock me. Never has. Stupid people getting paid to do stupid things: Same applies, doesn't bother me. That's different than seeing some guy walk into a bank and shoot someone. And cloning sheep. Well, it's not the matter of the physical cloning that we should care about, it's the stepping stones which are being laid. The good things that can come from cloning would be, for instance, organs. Let them clone 500 sheep, if it'll help with research.
By Shadow at Mar 28, 2002, 1:04 PM
|
0
SPLATJOB
63 posts
Quote: from Frank on 4:03 pm on Mar. 28, 2002[br]Sooo… what did all that ranting have to do with your original Jail inquery that I supported to begin with? �:)
Not really, no. But when I get started, I just gotta dance all night. ;)
By Murphy at Mar 28, 2002, 1:14 PM
|
0
LEGEND
951 posts
If television had not existed mankind wouldn't have been able to see the things that it has like the landing on the moon. People in Europe stayed up all night long to watch that since it was broadcast at a time for American viewers. Or the Berlin Wall coming down. Now imagine over a hundred years of that. Television shows like Survivor (which it seems is coming to Sindome if you believe the adverts) are a new phenomena that would go away if people stopped watching. But lets face it, its a fact of life (an anthropology) we like watching things like that because it fills us with secret joy to know we aren't the most pathetic people out there.
Onto the jail thing. I think it would be rather cool just to give it a trial run. Have a few people locked up for a week or so in the prison on RED. Let their friends and loved ones get visitors passes and come see them in the waiting room. You could hire people as prison guards. There's another form of employment right there. You could even get crooked guards who slips weapons and drugs to inmates for a fee. There's another form of potential crime. The players would still be able to log in and do some rp. They could lift weights in the yard or make AV plates or something. And if at the end of the trail run, say of a month, no one liked it then just can the idea permanently.
By Tash at Mar 29, 2002, 2:39 AM
|
0
BATA
261 posts
Off topic, but here goes..
TV -was- a worthwhile invention, more or less. It created plenty of jobs in the form of gyms and Weight Watchers clinics, and a greater market for greasy snack foods. It also permitted the dissemination of information. But then, it began to serve as a propaganda tool, and the high costs associated with TV means that the common man or woman will never be acbe to affect the programming and much less share one's opinion with the world. It's become a tool for media barons to spin the news and public opinion in their favor, it's all just about money, pure and simple. Now, with the internet a reality and the rise of broadband connections, television is or will be obsolete. We have here a medium which allows ANYONE with the will, a way to express themselves, share their opinions, and see/read the 'news' from hundreds upon thousands of different sources, thus allowing them to form their own opinions. There is no longer any excuse for ignorance except laziness. You want to know something, take the time and you will know it. Another thing that concerns me is this media baron phenomenon - people owning multiple newspapers and television stations (mainly here in North America). Shouldn't that be flat-out illegal, as it standardizes the information, opinions and newscasting that people can see? It's disgusting. Now, I don't know about all countries in Europe, but specifically in Greece, there are over 100 -National- newspapers, all owned and written by different people. No syndicated articles. Each newspaper is different, and together represent the entire spectrum of political opinion in that country. And THAT'S what makes sense to me.
Yeah, and as for prison, the core concept here would be to make it an -interesting- place to be. Not more fun that the outside game, and certainly not as fun, but still give players something to do in there. This could possibly even tie in with the suggested GM-run crime boss theme, whereas Prison would be a good place to meet shady characters who either are or know NPC crime bosses who could give the players little 'tasks' - both in prison (a la Maurice 'Mom' Boucher) and maybe outside. And instead of money, people could trade cigs (that's not just a stereotype, by the way). I'm surprised no one made any soap/shower references.
By Murphy at Mar 29, 2002, 8:59 AM
|
0
LEGEND
951 posts
Okay, to answer the original question about jail time.. the main reason most of us were against it is because it would need to be an automated process. You are basically putting a player outside of the game, which is what we do when we cell abusive players. That would now be in the hands of players. If this process is not automated in some way and you have to rely on players, the WJF or prison guards, to let the prisoner out.. then that person might be there much longer than intended. We had one player detained in the WJF cells for weeks and he didn't even commit a crime. The reason he was there that long? They forgot about the poor guy and he was never online at the same time the Judges that stuck him there were.
The prison… that isn't staying where it is. So, just forget about it's location... the real prison is out in the badlands. I do like some of those ideas on how to make time in prison more interesting and if we can work out a way to make sure players are released when they're supposed to be, I think it could be a viable option.
By FireStorm at Mar 29, 2002, 5:19 PM
|
0
BATA
210 posts
Well, prisoners released on time…you don't need players to do that, or admins.
You know how the WJF Employment terminal works, it's payday, so you go use it, type in payment and out comes your pay?
Well, you make a similar prison terminal, that detects a prisoner's SIC number or player number or whatever(like the SIC terminals?).When this prisoner goes to the terminal, he can see the remaining time on his sentence. When his time's up, he goes to the terminal, types in something like 'release' and gets a coded one-use bracelet. He puts on his coded bracelet, goes up to the 'exit area', which would function sort of like an airlock, a two-door (at least) system. Door A opens for the bracelet, con goes in. I don't know if the following is possible code-wise, but the room detects the number of occupants. If there's more than one, the door doesnt open until the sneaky git who followed bracelet-man gets the hell OUT. When the room is clear, Door A locks behind bracelet-lad, and door B in front opens. There, the releasee gets to change out of his prison jumpsuit and gets a few materials to make something wearable, and out he goes into the big bad world. By now, this bracelet is useless, so he can't go back in or give it to anyone else. Burned out, de-magnetized, magnetized, carbonized, vulcanized, fried, sauteed, boiled, I dunno.
Or something.
By Murphy at Mar 29, 2002, 8:30 PM
|
0
LEGEND
951 posts
The idea of a prison sentence is rather appealing, yeah, I know that we have the threat of being shot on site, but that's rather drastic for petty crimes (yeah yeah i know it's supposed to be a gritty, futuristic, corrupt society and what not… but still)
Even if you do have a clone waiting for you on the other side, your tempted not to do the PETTY crime stuff in order to build up a crime base / contacts / �knowledge� because of the unbalanced crime/punishment ratio. It would be just aggravating (that�s all) to have to start over at making all your weapons contacts if your executed all the time for simple possesion. I mean for the most part in real life you don�t get to be a mob �boss� or whatever without having done your fair share of the petty grunt work stuff.
Plus the more petty crime things a character would be shot for the more it would get annoying to try and get away with them (of course that raises the issue that they might want to reevaluate a life of crime if they can�t get away with even the petty stuff� ;) )
But like someone mentioned on another post, for the most part we are RPing a human character, and with those human characteristics their comes those �I don�t like to be killed too often� feelings. Call it being wussy. But I think even IRL if I did have a nice warm clone waiting for me in case I died, I still would take all the precautions of safety and smarts so as to prevent my death. If that makes sense� And I would avoid situations where dealing with the annoyance of my death outweighs any benefits to me.
Personally I would rather wander around a prison for a few hours to a day or so making contacts, RPing with other prisoners, taunting the guards, picking my nose� what have you, then having to deal with trying to remember what the hell just happened and why am I missing my socks?
But if prison sentences where to be carried out, just an added idea, maybe all the legal stuff in your inventory could, at the beginning of your prison stay be put into a cubbyhole, so that it�s waiting for you at the end of your stay. Of course just like in real life you could have a situation of,
Prison guard �Here�s your crap back buddy. Enjoy.�
Freedom loving X-prisoner after inspecting all the stuff, �Hey, I had a watch in here.�
Prison Guard �No you didn�t�
You �No I swear, it was cheap but it told the time� My Uncle Bobo gave it to me� and��
Prison guard raising his truncheon �I SAID� No you didn�t�
You meekly going on your way.
Maybe we can retain all the flavorings of a supposed rogue and tyrannical justice system by leaving the final decision REALLY up to the judges etc.. prison sentence or death� is the Judge in a pissy mood or feeling happy cause they got some candy? It all comes down to that.
But I guess all this is a moot point for now, if the prison is to be moved into the badlands� and those are supposed to be buggy themseves anyways.
But it would be a cool idea i think.
peash
izy
By Bias at Mar 30, 2002, 10:52 AM
|
0
GATO
568 posts
Yes, I like these ideas and all of them are quite feasible and would open up a whole new little world of RP and fun? hehe
Yes, it will be out in the badlands and yes that is still in need of some work, but that doesn't mean it can't be implemented before the badlands is fixed… it only means it cannot be accessed via exiting the dome by foot and travelling through the badlands.
Prisoners would be shuttled off from WHJ in some sort of armored AV perhaps.
Also, people are not shot for petty crimes. You've got to do something fairly brutal like murder to be executed. Otherwise you are fined. So, unless you killed somebody you really shouldn't have to worry about getting shot by a Judge. Odds are you're going to get shot by whomever it is you're stealing from instead of the Judge.
By FireStorm at Mar 30, 2002, 11:11 AM
|
0
BATA
210 posts
Ok think of it ICly.
The dome, 65million people. Why was the WJF formed for anyway and why do they use the marshall law approach? Because it is the cheapest and the fastest way to deal with criminals. In the U.S. today the death penalty costs more than a life sentence because of court appeals and paperwork. Well, in 2087, the street is the court, appeals take minutes and the paperwork is minimal. This is the most efficient way of dealing with criminals. And it's not even REAL death…you have a second chance, and a third...etc.
Now...in the case of the ultimate crimes: Mass murder, Multiple Judge kills, repeated acts of terrorism, where IRL it'd be ABSOLUTE death, and since we don't encourage PKing, so there will be a place where criminals will be sent away from the general public. WHether it'll be a place of good RP, i unno, whether it'll be a stasis, I unno. Perhaps in these instances we -could- approve an alternate character while the other char serves out a sentence and rehabilitations. The prisoner's stats get turned from Machinegun to knitting like in Demolition Man.
That's an IC explanations.
OOCly, newbies (who are most often the ones being sentenced) WILL get bored easily if they are locked up for a long time.
By Stonemonk at Mar 30, 2002, 11:19 AM
|
0
STREET SAM
435 posts
Newbies would get bored being locked up, but the alternative is to fine them, and if they don't make the money in time, we shoot 'em…so if they don't have a clone, they lose their character. Which sucks a lot more.
Especially since they assume, because they're newbies, that we Judges'll go easy on 'em *snickers* or they think they can come up with a lame lie and think it'll work.
So yeah, they drop like flies. This can be annoying to them, especially if they've just had their history approved. And even if someone drags the corpse to Genetek, by then they might've gone to the light, so it's pretty much a waste of cash in the end.
(Edited by Murphy at 3:06 pm on Mar. 30, 2002)
By Murphy at Mar 30, 2002, 12:05 PM
|
0
LEGEND
951 posts
Well as a newbie, i know i wouldn't get too bored if their was a good RPing prison scenario… but i don't get bored when i'm just staring at the pretty lights on my walls.. so.. well take that as you will. ;)
By Bias at Mar 30, 2002, 10:34 PM
|
0
GATO
568 posts
I understand what your sayin, but how bout for repeat offenders, normally the vets, you put em in prison, I do think that they will then try to be more daring, cause they won't risk clone death. i would
bottom line
IT DOESN'T PAY TO BE A CRIMINAL
I remember Johnny said one time, we are the cream of the crop, there is the ambient pop, so if we commit a crime wouldn't we be treated diff then the others?
By Dominik at Mar 30, 2002, 11:15 PM
|
0
BATA
282 posts
For prison sentences to be a worthwhile deterrant they need to be of a significant length and most of the length of time -will- be spent alone simply because the player base isn't big enough to fill the dome, let alone a secondary enclosed enviroment within the dome. Players who are imprisoned -do- get bored and -do- get frustrated. What happens when players get imprisoned, be they oldbie, newbie or somewhereinbetweenbie? They frantically search for some way to kill themselves and when they can't kill themselves the maniacally badger and harrass admin about how bored they are.
Calling them poor RPers is a dead argument. I've seen some fine RPers use this very piss-poor 'get out of jail free' card many times on multiple M*'s.
Prison time does NOT work. Not here. Not there. Not anywhere… cept maybe PrisonMOO. Anyone up to RP some quality showertime with Bubba?
By Rastus at Mar 31, 2002, 10:51 PM
|
0
ACE KOOL
610 posts
Course, one thing I suggested -long- ago and that could tie in with Tash's post about alts was using imprisonment as an alternative/varient on the vacation system idea. When your character is imprisoned it's stored, your ability to connect blocked and a new character generated for you and dropped into chargen. You're forced to play this character, or subsequent chars on perma-death, until the 'release date' of your previous character at which point you can either choose to resume play of your main character or optionally extend your prison time for 'bad behaviour' or something.
The logic of the system would be refining, but hey, it's a suggestion. Only problem I do see is if one person were to have multiple imprisonments. Perhaps only let a player have his/her primary character imprisoned and any characters imprisoned after that, being 'secondary characters', are lost as if perm'd. Iunno… jus' a thought.
By Rastus at Mar 31, 2002, 10:57 PM
|
0
ACE KOOL
610 posts
I personally wouldn't be bothered by being locked up for a while, and in fact, I can see it making some fun RP if anyone decided to try some crazy jailbreak, but, realistically, a few days in prison isn't much of a punishment, nor is it a deterent.
Fines make good punishments, because they sting people where it hurts most, in the wallet. It's a material world, material wealth is what most players are aiming for.
I actually think clone executions are pointless though. You don't learn anything if you don't remember it, so chances are, if you kill someone, they're going to offend again.
If you pass a fine on someone, that they can't pay, maybe judges could serve a community service order on people or something, so they have to work off thier "debt to society" make them clear up bodies, clean up graffitti, sweep the streets, until they've paid thier debt. And if they refuse to that, -then- you execute them, or something.
Oh, and on a not really related note, the first bit of the website, has a judge saying "Sentenced to death by execution" as opposed to what, sentenced to 3 days in prison by execution :P.
By King[Fu] at Apr 7, 2002, 4:11 AM
|
0
BATA
255 posts
King Fu-They do have community service, of sorts….*ahem* This is what I heard, from a player called Syphon. :). He did some bad stuff, got caught, and got fined 100k. No way in hell he could pay, so they made him work at WCS to work off the debt. They were to take out 3k from his paycheck a week. Not that Syphon was gonna do that, but still.
(Edited by Shadow at 6:33 pm on April 7, 2002)
By Shadow at Apr 7, 2002, 6:31 PM
|
0
SPLATJOB
63 posts
On a note about Murphy's 10k legs, Cook County Hospital in Chi-town has a pair of legs that allow parapalegics the chance to walk. They are being used for physical therapy so the muscles don't atrophy.
By DaveK at Apr 7, 2002, 6:45 PM
|
0
SPLATJOB
53 posts
How old is this idea? Like 2 years? I was just reading it, and alot of the ideas, well most of them, sounded really cool. Street characters can get reps from being in the pen, and you could fall into some crazy jail gang, have dirty guards, meet gun runners, assasins, etc. and tons of other junk. So, like, what do you guys/girls think of this idea now?
By Biohazard at Nov 14, 2004, 3:07 PM
|
0
LEGEND
938 posts
On topic I think it is a good idea to have the jail working so you can not only save moneyu but it would increase crime rate on a great level.
By Nayr at Nov 16, 2004, 10:22 AM
|
0
BAKALAKA
122 posts
I think it is a good idea to have the jail working so you can not only save moneyu but it would increase crime rate on a great level.
Sorry, how's that?
I fail to see how either of the two things mention happens as a result of having a jail.
If people we're being locked away instead of cloned and put back on the street, wouldn't that make for less criminals? And is less criminal activity the desired result?
And how does having a jail help you save money? It's not like this would be a 'free place to live'. It would probablly be a really shitty place to be… right?
-Kevlar
By Kevlar at Nov 16, 2004, 4:31 PM
|
0
LEGEND
977 posts
I"m Anti-Jail, definitly. I mean, in order for there to be any RP going on -in- the jail, that would mean there has to be GMs around to puppet and all that. Plus there would have to be other players in jail.. yadda yadda. So it would be a detriment to RP.
I don't even see why there would be a jail ICly. Unless its like a cryo prison or something. Why the hell would the corps spend money on keeping people in prison when they can just clone death them (and then the people have to pay for new clones) and slap them with a hefty fine..
Jail just doesn't make sense at -all-.
By Nemisis at Nov 16, 2004, 10:09 PM
|
0
LEGEND
770 posts
Cryoprison.
Frozen meat popsicles don't need a lot of guards. And they can't do anything bad either. And it forces PLAYERS to make new CHARACTERS because thier first CHARACTER is a POPSICLE for, oh, say 2 years.
By Iga at Nov 17, 2004, 10:59 AM
|
0
LEGEND
1,294 posts