This would be a nice feature so that there's a middle ground between freshly applied makeup and no makeup at all. (If you really wanted, it could depreciate on its own, but that may be more work than it is worth. People can just use the command.)
Here are some thoughts for those messages:
is smeared messily above her eyes.
is streaky, a dark halo around her eyes.
is runny, leaving dark streaks down her cheeks.
is smudged and faded around her lips.